So, the internet searches began. I found a few different recipes and finally settled on this one... mostly because it had pictures and the blogger thoroughly described each step. I didn't want to screw this up.
Old-Time Burnt Sugar Cake
Ok... you've seen the picture. Need I say more?
This may be one of the moistest, flavorful cakes I have ever had. It is nice and dense like a home made banana cake, but with a flavor and richness that is all its own. The frosting that the recipe calls for actually didn't work out for me. It had a nice caramel flavor after it sat a bit, but I think it just had way too much powdered sugar for my taste. Some might like it just fine, but I really thought I could do better. So I did.
Caramel Frosting II Recipe
This frosting was outstanding. I didn't want to stop eating it. There are a million different ways of making caramel frosting, and I actually picked this one because it seemed like one of the simplest recipes and had a lot of good reviews. I've only made my own frosting a handful of times, but this was the closest to what I was used to. I guess I knew I really couldn't go wrong when it started by melting a stick of butter with a cup of brown sugar.
So, if you'd like to try your hand at this unique cake, I have two suggestions:
- Reduce the amount of burnt sugar you make in the recipe (you only use 1/2 cup for the actual cake, the rest is reserved for the frosting) and make the caramel frosting instead.
- Work quickly when spreading the caramel frosting. It sets up pretty fast and I just barely finished frosting the cake before it was really starting to harden and clump on me.
I know this cake doesn't win any points for being "light," but it certainly gets a 5/5 review from me for sweetness, texture, and flavor. Hey, if you're gonna splurge, might as well make it worth it!
Oh, and my yahtzee buddy? She loved it!